Miu MiuPradaMarc JacobsRhinebeck, New YorkDesigner ConsignmentCurated VintageTracy ReeseGift Cards AvailableNew Arrivals Weekly6822 Route 9 Miu MiuPradaMarc JacobsRhinebeck, New YorkDesigner ConsignmentCurated VintageTracy ReeseGift Cards AvailableNew Arrivals Weekly6822 Route 9

Rhinebeck, New York · Founded by Lisa Metcalfe

A closet
worth discovering.

Curated designer consignment — Prada, Miu Miu, Marc Jacobs, and beyond. Thirty-eight years of an unteachable eye, hand-selecting every piece.

Curated designer rack
Currently stocked
200+ designer pieces

Just Landed

New arrivals

Fresh inventory added weekly. Follow @ultimatethrift.shop for first looks.

Lisa Metcalfe, founder
38
Years in fashion

Meet Lisa

A barn, a flyer,
and 38 years of taste

Lisa Metcalfe spent decades inside the fashion industry, beginning in production at Calvin Klein in the 1980s and going on to advise fashion businesses for the better part of four decades. When she and her husband settled full-time in the Hudson Valley, she brought four decades of closets, contacts, and an unteachable eye with her.

In August 2023, Lisa cleared out her barn — thirty-eight years of accumulated treasures — and rented a small space in Rhinebeck for a weekend. Her college-aged daughter designed a 90's-themed flyer. The racks were borrowed. The crowd that showed up didn't expect much, and left talking about it for weeks — old-school Barney's warehouse sale energy, in the middle of Dutchess County.

"We're not a bin store. We're not a rack. We're a boutique that happens to be second-hand."

What began as a clear-out became a calling. Loyal shoppers turned into consignors. The pop-ups turned into a permanent home at 6822 Route 9. Today Lisa still pops up only when she's curated something worth the trip — because after a lifetime in fashion, she's certain this is where it's heading: beautiful, well-loved pieces, given a second chapter, by someone who knows exactly what she's looking at.

1980s
Began at Calvin Klein
2023
First Rhinebeck pop-up
200+
Loyal consignors

Visit Us

Find your way here

Location
6822 Route 9
Rhinebeck, New York 12572
Free parking on-site
Hours
Open Friday – Sunday
Wed – Thu: By appointment
Fri – Sat: 11am – 6pm
Sun: 12pm – 5pm
Get in Touch
@ultimatethrift.shop
Instagram DMs welcome
Gift cards available in-store
Book a private appointment

Consign With Us

Your closet,
our stage

Moved up from the city? Clearing out your wardrobe? We connect your designer pieces with buyers who'll love them. Lisa handles everything — you just drop off.

Your bag

Your bag is empty